(Message sent via IEEE Standards webmail) ----------------------------------------- Commenter = Glen Kramer Affiliation = Broadcom SenderEmail = gkramer@broadcom.com SenderPhone = (707)529-0917 StandardRev = IEEE Std 1904.1-2013 SubclauseNumber = 7.3.1.3 Page = 104 Rationale = "The Replace Tag operation may replace the entire selected tag or only one subfield of B- Tag, I-Tag, or I-Header fields. The operation shall be capable of altering the following subfields: B-DA, B-SA, B_TAG, B-TPID, B-PCP, B-DEI, B-VID, I_TAG, I-TPID, I-PCP, I-DEI, I-UCA, I-RES, I-SID, and I_HEADER." The above text mixes field names (like B-SA, I-TPID) with field codes that are to be used only in the code examples (B_TAG, I_HEADER). ProposedChange = Delete words "B_TAG", "I_TAG", and "I_HEADER" from the second sentence. These are not subfields and the preceding sentence already states that these fields can be replaced. Impact = None. This change does not alter the Replace Tag operation. It just makes the description consistent with the conventions used in the standard. ----------------------------------------- (End of IEEE Standards webmail message)