Call 5/31/2016 notes
Start: 5/31/2016 08:00 PDT
End: 5/31/2016 09:15 PDT
Present:
Jouni Korhonen
Bob Deletto
Rami Al-odaibi
Richard Tse
Stuart Whitehead
Bomin Li
Brian Torley
Xhafer Krasniqi
Steinar Bjornstad
Stefano ?
Ralph Bechstein
Ofir Mahazri
Richard Maiden
Kevin Bross
Actual agenda:
* Jouni presented timestamp and late packet detection document:
http://www.ieee1904.org/3/email/msg00497.html
* Richard M. start discussion around whether late packets can
be detected using other mechanisms.
* Jouni agrees there are many ways to do that but they also
require more tracking/state etc compared to "good timestamp
window" comparison.
* Brian T. points out that the presentation time can be beyond
what the receiver can buffer and this should be taken into
considerations when setting the window for the presentation
time. Jouni agrees to note this in therevision of the
presentation.
* There is no way to dynamically negotiate the value and it is
set "somehow". Arguments whether such value is entirely
implementation detail. Jouni points out that both sender and
receiver have to have same agreement on the algorithm for
the timestamp and know the bounds.
* Spec Draft D1.0 still on hold due some word->pdf conversion
issues. Will be resolved asap. Commenting period starts
immediately when the draft D1.0 is available and Jouni will
also then announce the deadline for the first commenting
period.
* Jouni goes through the commenting process..
* Question about required technical comments that have no
solution proposal. Those are possible but in general there
should be a solution proposal otherwise the editor has no
good way to address the issue. One approach is to first
come up with a discussion papers as well going through
the issue properly.
* We hopefully have the first round of comments by the f2f
meeting to go through.
* For the 1904.3 TF meeting in June.. if there are guestions
check the info material and/or ask Bomin Li for details:
http://www.ieee1904.org/wg_wrapper.shtml?/meeting_info/2016/anwg_1606_mtg_info.pdf
bli@xxxxxxxxxxxx
* We try to prototype remote participation to the TF
meeting as well. Jouni will post more details later on
(like the webex numbers).
* Jouni tells the latest regarding merger of 1904.e 3 RoE TF
and 1914 WG. The sponsor (ComSoc/SDB) of both WGs (1904 and
1914) agreed the move of PAR 5/23/16. The PAR where RoE is
under 1914 NGFI WG as P1914.3 will be considered at the
29-Jun-2016 NesCom meeting.
* Jouni reminds about the 1904.3 TF f2f document deadline,
which should be 6/11/16 EOB PDT. Jouni already announced
two inputs: 1) timestamps and late packets, 2) proposal
for start of frame tracking.
Next call:
* 6/14/2016 8AM PDT