(Message sent via IEEE Standards webmail)
-----------------------------------------

Commenter = Glen Kramer
Affiliation = Broadcom
SenderEmail = gkramer@broadcom.com
SenderPhone = (707)529-0917
StandardRev = IEEE Std 1904.1-2013
SubclauseNumber = 14.4.3.6.1.3
Page = 619
Rationale = Wrong context objects for aRuleSetConfig attribute.

The aRuleSetConfig attribute is associated with the ONU, PON Port, LLID, UNI Port, or Queue object (see
14.4.1.1).

Per DPoE, it should be only UNI port or PON port.


ProposedChange = Replace 

"The aRuleSetConfig attribute is associated with the ONU, PON Port, LLID, UNI Port, or Queue object 
(see 14.4.1.1)."

With

"The aRuleSetConfig attribute is associated with the PON Port or UNI Port object (see 14.4.1.1)."


Impact = ONUs compliant with this MR may reject non-complaint OLT's attempt to set a rule with a 
wrong context object. Unknown if any deployments use ONU, LLID, or Queue objects for this attribute.

-----------------------------------------
(End of IEEE Standards webmail message)